As we get closer to BETT 2011 I thought I would do a bit of research into reasons why schools and universities would chose Moodle over the competition.
There have been a number of reports recently of organisations moving from Blackboard to Moodle with a variety of reasons being given, the most consistent being the huge saving that comes with eliminating the annual license fee. I read a report from Vasaar College who estimated a saving of $50,000 annually by switching from the commercial Blackboard to the Open Source Moodle.
But the huge money saving was not the only reason for Vasaars decision to switch VLE, as explained by various members of their team…
Jeffrey Schneider, an Associate Professor commented on the different reasons the faculty where drawn to Moodle.
“A sizable majority of [the faculty] were dissatisfied with Blackboard—it seemed really limited and didn’t offer the same kind of metaphor for learning. It was very teacher directed and felt more fake and artificial. Moodle is a much more attractive, flexible interface.”
Associate Professor Rachel Friedman, who uses elearning in her classes, pointed out what she considers to be the advantage of Moodle:
“The automatic layout of the semester week-by-week, for example, allows for an “interactive” syllabus—not a frozen document, but something that evolves in response to what is actually happening in the classroom.”
Steve Taylor, a member of Vasaar’s Moodle Support team tells it from a technician’s point of view:
“Technologically speaking, Moodle is easier to maintain than Blackboard because it is an open-source software—a program whose code is accessible to those running the site.
“This means that if there’s a little bug, or if we want a function to behave differently or if someone has created a great new function, we can modify the program. We’ve made lots of modifications and while that has called for some work on our part, it’s resulted in a system that better meets the users’ needs,”
Another school that recently made the move from Blackboard to Moodle is the North Shore Senior High School. Again their district viewed Blackboard as being a, “huge investment that was putting a hole in their tight overall budget.”
A report by the school’s newsletter described Moodle as being:
“a stronger [version] of Blackboard which includes more advanced features that allow teachers to become more involved in a student’s academic future”
Some of the specific advantages of Moodle outlined by North Shore include:
“it promotes frequent feedback to students. Students are sent email notices when an instructor has posted grades, added feedback to an assignment, and an assignment can be updated.”
“The grade book tool in Moodle lets you add feedback in addition to a grade or score. Built-in blog and wiki tools in Moodle provide new communication options for group work and journals.”
“Moodle students can access all of the course resources from the course front page.”
Over all North Shore concluded that as well as saving money, Moodle provided a site that was much more personalised and flexible.
Introducing Moodle 2.0
Another topic that is sure to be a hot one at BETT 2011 is the release of Moodle 2.0. With the release of Moodle 2.0 comes a whole host of new and improved features that continues to set Moodle apart from the competition.
The Open University, who operate one of the world’s largest VLE’s, has recently reviewed their options in the light of the advances made with the various software options.
Having looked at the functionality offered by current and future editions of Moodle, Blackboard, Desire2Learn and Sakai it was concluded that the new Moodle 2.0 was best suited to the Open Universities requirements.
A current consideration for organisations using Moodle will be how to introduce Moodle 2.0 as efficiently as possible. Ross McKenzie, Strategic Development Manager at the Open University, explains how they plan to execute the transition to Moodle 2.0:
“The first student-ready release of our new OUVLE will come online in June 2011, with a follow-up release in September 2011. We’re planning to run the new OUVLE alongside the existing Moodle-1.9-based OUVLE for at least 12 months, and we’ll be gradually moving students over to the new OUVLE during that period.”
It is inevitable that with Moodle 2.0 being such a major release a lot of Moodle users will want a transitional period for introducing Moodle 2.0 so as to cause as little disruption to their operations as possible.
We have factored this into our Moodle 2.0 upgrade packages, offering a number of ‘Test Options’ that give Moodlers the chance to play around with a Moodle course, test site or duplicate site. This means you can acquaint yourself with all the new features that come with Moodle 2.0 before introducing it fully.
For more information on our various ‘Route to Moodle 2.0′ options click here
Join our network








Share this link











